Headline: The Atlantic Transort Line 

Home    |    History    |    Ships    |    Miscellanea    |    Search   

 

The only photograph of the Mohegan known to exist

S.S. Mohegan

Other name: Cleopatra
Sisters: Menominee, Manitou, Mesaba, Marquette
Builder: Earle's Shipbuilding and Engineering Co., Hull
Launched April 6, 1898; maiden voyage July 31, 1898; wrecked October 14, 1898
Hull: length 475'; beam 52'; 6,889 tons; 2 steel decks; 8 watertight bulkheads
Power: single screw; triple expansion engine by builder with cylinders of 32", 54", and 90" diameter, stroke 66," rated at 5,000 I.H.P.
2 double ended and one single ended boilers fitted with Howden draft and operating at 200 p.s.i.
Registered in Hull; official number 109043

 

The Mohegan was built originally for the Wilson & Furness-Leyland Line's New York service as the Cleopatra. She had stalls for 700 cattle and "an improved system of sanitation rendering the cattle carrying quite free from annoyance to passengers." She was one of five new sister ships purchased from the Wilson & Furness-Leyland Line for £140,000 each to replace vessels bought by the U. S. government for use as transports in the Spanish-American War. The Cleopatra, the only one of these ships built in Hull, was the youngest of the sisters and she was still in her builder's yard when she changed hands.

Described by the Hull Daily Mail as "the longest vessel ever built at Hull" the Cleopatra boasted "a large handsome dining saloon in polished oak with carved panels and pilasters being situated under the bridge deck" and, "In the house are a large music room, decorated in ivory colour and gold, a smoking room in polished oak and a considerable number of State rooms." Her maiden voyage did not go well because she had major problems with her boilers and pumps. She broke down completely on several occasions and reportedly her plumbing was also defective and some state rooms flooded. Passengers protested to the line about the condition of the vessel, but signed a testimonial to "the splendid conduct of the officers and crew." The Cleopatra eventually reached New York on August 12 and was sent back three days later for repairs in England without taking on any passengers.

These extensive repairs delayed Cleopatra's second voyage for two months. Among those inconvenienced were Julia and Lemuel Potwin, whose journal (412 KB PDF file) records that they had booked to sail home on Cleopatra, but because she was still undergoing repairs they had to spend an additional week in London (for which they were rather grateful) and sailed instead on her sister Victoria. Meanwhile all five of the ex- Wilson & Furness-Leyland Line ships had been renamed in September to conform to the line's house style. The Cleopatra became the Mohegan. She was sent for a fresh set of trials in the North Sea and was pronounced satisfactory. She was then rigorously reinspected by the Board of Trade and was issued with a new certificate. Lloyds of London classified her "100 A1."

The Mohegan sailed on her second voyage on October 13, 1898 carrying 97 crew, 6 cattlemen, 1 horseman and 1,286 tons of general cargo. She collected 53 passengers at Gravesend and dropped her Trinity House pilot at Dover at 7:30 p.m. A letter to the Engineering Superintendent (3,213 KB PDF file) from Assistant Engineer William Kinley probably came ashore when the pilot left the ship at 7:55. In the letter Kinley reported minor teething troubles but no major issues with the ship other than a shortage of steam caused by the new team of firemen not being "up to the mark." From Dover the Mohegan steamed down the channel heading for New York. But when making a routine alteration to her course as she hugged the coast of Cornwall late the following afternoon she inexplicably followed the wrong bearing. Instead of heading for the clear water south of the Lizard Peninsula she steamed directly towards the coast and then at almost the last moment, presumably as the mistake was perceived on board, turned to the south. Tragically, while her new course avoided the shore it also led her directly onto the most dangerous rocks in the area.

As dinner was being served the ship's engine was stopped but almost simultaneously she hit the notorious rock Maen Voes and the impact tore off her rudder. Momentum then carried her rapidly forwards 450 feet onto the Manacles, the infamous granite reef beyond. According to one of the survivors, "suddenly there was an awful sound as though the ships bottom was being torn out." The ship developed a severe list and sank in about 12 minutes at dusk as a gale was blowing. She carried more than enough lifeboats for everyone on board but it proved extremely difficult to launch them. Of the two boats successfully lowered one overturned and the other was swamped. Some passengers and crew climbed into the rigging but most went to the stern, from where they were soon washed overboard. The coxswain of the nearby lifeboat at Porthoustock had seen the Mohegan approach and turn towards the Manacles, and called his crew out before the ship struck, but it was a long row to the site of the wreck. The Porthoustock lifeboat rescued most of the 50 passengers and crew saved that night, but 106 people, most of them passengers, died in the disaster (The Mohegan's Passengers and Crew). The disaster was widely covered in the press (Dundee Courier, Monday October 17, 1898, for example) and was later commemorated by the infamous Scottish tragedian William McGonagall with a poem that was bad even by his standards.

This was by far the greatest disaster in the history of the Atlantic Transport Line, and the Board of Trade held an official inquiry in London which determined that the cause was "that a wrong course — W. by N. — .was steered after passing the Eddystone, at 4.17 p.m." It seems likely that Captain Griffiths made navigational errors that were not recognized or acted upon until it was too late, but with Captain Griffiths and all of the navigating officers dead it was not possible to ascertain the cause of the accident. Conspiracy theories about the Mohegan can be traced back to within weeks of the disaster but don't bear examination. The Atlantic Transport Line clearly held Griffiths — their most senior captain — in high regard and there is no evidence of any dispute between them. And Griffiths could not benefit from any insurance payout. Furthermore, his ship had been insured for £28,000 less than had been had been paid for her. (To reduce its insurance costs the Atlantic Transport Line maintained a "special insurance fund,' and "ran a large risk" on each of its vessels.)

Today what is left of the wreck is very popular with divers because it is accessible, interesting, and still occasionally yields crockery and brass portholes.

Sources: The Atlantic Transport Line, 1881-1931; The Ships List; shipwreckcharlestown.com; The Mohegan, 1898-1998, Terry Moyle, Kent, 1998; st-keverne.com; Passenger Ships of the World Past and Present, Eugene W. Smith, Massachusetts, 1977; Fourteen Months Abroad, Julia Hedges Potwin, published privately, Cleveland, Ohio, 1911; The New York Times, October 16, 1898; October 30, 1898, November 8, 1898

The only photograph of the Mohegan known to exist
The only photograph of the Mohegan known to exist

Captain Grigffith of the MoheganWilliam Kinley (Martin Kinley)
Left: Captain Richard Griffiths of the Mohegan, senior commander of the line. (Illustrated London News)
Right: Assistant Engineer William Kinley, on board "as a supernumerary on behalf of the owners" (Martin Kinley)

The report sent from the Mohegan to the line's superintending engineer in London by William Kinley the evening before the ship was wrecked on October 14, 1898 (Kinghorn)
The report sent from the Mohegan to the line's superintending engineer in London by William Kinley
the evening before the ship was wrecked on October 14, 1898 (Kinghorn)
Click for PDF file (3,213 KB)

Llewellyn Crouch, Chief Officer of the MoheganEarnest Cole,  Second Officer of the Mohegan
Two victims of the disaster: Left: Llewellyn Crouch, Chief Officer of the Mohegan.
Right: Earnest Cole, Second Officer of the Mohegan. (Illustrated London News)

The only photograph of the Mohegan known to exist
A sketch of the Mohegan (The Dundee Courier, Monday October 17, 1898)

photo of a promenade deck cabin from 1909 ATL brochure
A state room on the Mohegan's sister Mesaba, from a 1909 Atlantic Transport Line brochure (Kinghorn)

Passenger's snap of Menominee's boat deck showing how little space there was
This passenger's snap of the Mohegan's sister Menomnee c.1903 shows the limited space in which the lifeboats had to be launched.
In the background an officer can be seen on the bridge, from where Captain Griffiths gave his orders as his ship sank. (Ian Newson)

Map showing Mohegan's approximate route and indicating the course she shouls have been following
This map shows in gray the approximate course that the Mohegan should have followed after passing the Eddystone Lighthouse and in black the more northerly course that led to the disaster

Mohegan's wreck seen from shore soon after the disaster (Martin Kinley)
The wreck of the Mohegan photographed from the mainland soon after the disaster, showing the reef on which she struck. Note the spectators on the rocks in the foreground. (Martin Kinley)

Tinted postcard of the wreck of the Mohegan
This photograph shows how close the Mohegan came to safety -- had she steamed the other side of the buoy in the foreground there would
have been no disaster. It was taken before the Mohegan's funnel collapsed in a storm about three weeks after the wreck.
This tinted postcard was mailed in 1905. (Kinghorn)

Mohegan wreck from Illustrated London News
The wreck as published by the Illustrated London News immediately after the disaster,
from a photograph by Major and Darker of Falmouth. (Newson)

newspaper photo of visitors to the wreck
Although the Mohegan sank in the dark a local newspaper published this image weeks later claiming that it shows passengers being rescued from the wreck.
The Atlantic Transport Line's marine superintendent described to the official inquiry taking a boat from the salvage tug to investigate the wreck at close quarters on October 19.
When close to the mizzen rigging it struck the wreck and began to sink and its occupants took to the rigging until rescued by one of the Trinity boats
anchored nearby. This photograph however, was taken weeks later, after the funnel had collapsed and probably shows sightseers.

the mass grave for Mohegan victims the memorial window given by the Atlantic Transport Line.
The mass grave for victims of the disaster in the parish church at Saint Keverne, and the memorial window given to the church by the Atlantic Transport Line.

A sketch for divers of the Mohegan wreck today
A sketch for divers showing the remains of the Mohegan today with the boilers clearly visible (John Liddiard)

diving on the wreck of the Mohegandiving on the wreck of the Mohegan
Divers exploring the wreck still occasionally find crockery and brass portholes (John Liddiard)

 

For more information ...

Kinghorn "The Atlantic Transport Line 1881 - 1931" McFarland, 2011

Home   |    History   |   Ships   |   Miscellanea   |   Search


© 2005 - 2014, Jonathan Kinghorn, all rights reserved

This Site and all its Contents are intended solely for non-commercial use. You may download or copy the Contents and other downloadable materials displayed on the Site for your personal use only. No right, title or interest in any downloaded materials or software is transferred to you as a result of any such downloading or copying. You may not reproduce (except as noted above), publish, transmit, distribute, display, modify, create derivative works from, sell or participate in any sale of or exploit in any way, in whole or in part, any of the Contents, the Site or any related software.